home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=91TT0721>
- <title>
- Apr. 08, 1991: Soviet Union:Russian Standoff
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1991
- Apr. 08, 1991 The Simple Life
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- WORLD, Page 36
- SOVIET UNION
- Russian Standoff
- </hdr><body>
- <p>Gorbachev's authority is stretched to the breaking point as
- thousands march for Yeltsin in Moscow and the miners' strike
- spreads
- </p>
- <p>By Bruce W. Nelan--Reported by James Carney/Donetsk, Ann
- Simmons/Moscow and J.F.O. McAllister/Washington
- </p>
- <p> The marchers, more than 200,000 strong, simply defied the
- government ban, the thousands of police, the scores of military
- vehicles. As an evening snow shower dusted their faces, the
- supporters of change in the Soviet Union thronged Moscow's
- streets to deliver a pungent political message, savoring the act
- of public assembly in the face of Mikhail Gorbachev's order
- forbidding rallies, and then tramped peacefully home. For what,
- then, had the Kremlin assembled an enormous security force--to protect itself against its own people?
- </p>
- <p> Gorbachev's futile show of force surely marked another
- drop in his waning popularity. Amid the ranks of uniformed men,
- a solitary woman stood weeping. "This is the country I love,"
- said Natalia Kositskaya, a 50-year-old doctor at a Moscow
- military clinic, "and I am ashamed of it. I never would have
- believed Gorbachev could do this. In the past two years, he has
- become a devil." Her tears continued as she pointed at the
- moving phalanx of police. "It is a crime," she said.
- </p>
- <p> Only two years ago, President Gorbachev was urging the
- Soviet people to be bold, to show initiative, to carry out
- demokratizatsiya at all levels. "Perestroika," he said, "is a
- revolution." That definition may have seemed all too literal to
- him last week as the marching Muscovites disobeyed him to prove
- their support for his main rival, Russian leader Boris Yeltsin.
- Just as ominously, thousands of striking miners, from the
- Ukraine to western Siberia, were also resorting to politics, and
- joined their city cousins in demanding Gorbachev's resignation.
- </p>
- <p> Like the whole of the ailing Soviet economy, the mine
- strike has been festering for years. But Gorbachev brought last
- week's confrontation in the capital on himself. Communists
- inside the Russian republic's parliament had called a special
- session to mount a no-confidence vote against Yeltsin. Many feel
- that the maverick Russian should be dismissed for demanding
- Gorbachev's resignation, for supporting the breakaway Baltic
- republics and for such other sins as suggesting a separate
- Russian army.
- </p>
- <p> Although Yeltsin holds support by only a thin margin in
- the 1,068-seat parliament, his position was strengthened three
- weeks ago by a question he inserted into the national
- referendum. Seventy percent of those who voted said yes to his
- idea of a popularly elected President, for which he would be the
- clear favorite. Last week's rally, for which plans had been
- announced even before the referendum, would burnish his image
- still further.
- </p>
- <p> Gorbachev struck back with a ban on all public
- demonstrations in Moscow for three weeks, suggesting that
- deputies in the Russian parliament would be intimidated if they
- had to wade through an ocean of yelling Yeltsinites. To make
- sure the ban was enforced, the President took police powers away
- from the city council and turned them over to the national
- Interior Ministry, which mustered a virtual army of trucks,
- water cannons and troops in riot gear. Prime Minister Valentin
- Pavlov spoke of "looming threats," and Anatoli Karpychev, deputy
- editor of Pravda, the party daily, charged that radicals were
- planning a coup. Declared he: "Preparations for the final
- storming of the Kremlin have already begun."
- </p>
- <p> On Thursday morning the streets of the capital were in the
- hands of 50,000 paramilitary police, soldiers and Interior
- Ministry troops. The squares and byways around the Kremlin were
- blocked by hundreds of heavy trucks, and the water cannons
- lurked like artillery behind the troops.
- </p>
- <p> Even before the demonstrations began, Gorbachev suffered
- his first political setback of the day. The Russian parliament
- voted almost 2-to-1 to overrule his decree against public
- marches and seizure of law-enforcement power. Then the deputies
- adjourned so Yeltsin backers could take part in the protest and
- help keep it peaceful.
- </p>
- <p> The rally organizers had planned to gather their marchers
- in public squares several blocks from the Kremlin and then move
- into Manezh Square. The crowds found they could not make it past
- the troops blocking the routes into the square, so they simply
- demonstrated in several places in the center of the city, and
- the police did not even try to break them up.
- </p>
- <p> In a display of what Gorbachev used to call "the
- creativity of the masses," people turned out on sidewalks,
- balconies and street corners. Thousands gathered in Mayakovsky
- Square and the Old Arbat, the designated meeting points,
- carrying rebellious posters: GORBACHEV RESIGN and SAVE RUSSIA
- FROM THE COMMUNIST PARTY. As they assembled, they chanted,
- "Yel-tsin! Yel-tsin!" and scolded the troops surrounding them,
- "Shame! Shame!"
- </p>
- <p> The day proved that if they have achieved nothing else,
- Gorbachev's reforms have wiped away Soviet citizens' fear of
- their government. "Despite a campaign of intimidation," Nikolai
- Travkin, head of the radical Democratic Party, told the crowd,
- "we have gathered here and crossed the threshold of fear." Their
- courage delivered another blow to Gorbachev's authority and a
- boost for the man fighting the Kremlin, Boris Yeltsin.
- </p>
- <p> National television's evening news has reverted to its old
- propagandistic habits, and so took the government's dismissive
- view of the day's events as "nothing new." Yet even the
- newsreader added, "We cannot fail to see that appeals for a
- change in leadership and a change in the system are being heard
- more and more frequently."
- </p>
- <p> Those appeals are also coming from important and angry
- segments of the work force on whose behalf the Russian
- Revolution established a "dictatorship of the proletariat." In
- the office of the miners' strike committee in Donetsk, coal
- capital of the Ukraine, a poster on one wall renders today's
- verdict on that myth. It shows a stylized Soviet worker in
- shackles, his neck ring labeled KGB, his iron waistband
- PROPAGANDA and the iron ball he carries COMMUNIST PARTY OF THE
- SOVIET UNION. Below is the caption: "We have nothing to lose but
- our chains."
- </p>
- <p> Yuri Marakov, 52, is co-chairman of the Donetsk strike
- committee and one of the leaders of the new free-union movement.
- Where once trade unions existed only to transmit production
- orders from the party, perestroika and the strikes of 1989 have
- given rise to unions that put the worker first. They are
- relatively small but influential. In addition to the miners,
- groups of seamen, air-traffic controllers and journalists have
- set up independent federations. Almost every mine has a
- permanent workers' committee. "People just want normal working
- and living conditions," says Marakov, "but they can't have
- normal conditions in this system."
- </p>
- <p> When the miners struck through much of the summer two
- years ago, they asked for higher pay, better housing, more
- consumer goods. Gorbachev praised their enterprise and promised
- to deliver. But he never did, and many miners still live in
- squalor and work with old equipment in dangerous conditions.
- They blame Gorbachev. "Before," says Marakov, "we made economic
- demands. Now we must make political demands."
- </p>
- <p> More than 300,000 miners are on strike at 200 of the
- country's 600 pits, and most of them are calling for Gorbachev's
- resignation. Inspired by the miners, workers in other industries
- are signaling that they are almost ready to lay down their
- tools. A wave of support rallies rolled through metalworks
- across the country last week, and the giant machine-building
- plant Uralmash in Sverdlovsk staged a two-hour warning strike.
- </p>
- <p> Moscow's bureaucrats seem as deaf as ever to such
- warnings. Asked by a TV correspondent about the merits of the
- strikers' demands, Mikhail Shchadov, Minister of the Coal
- Industry, replied with an obscenity. "This kind of language,"
- said a miner in Kemerovo, "is the only thing the minister has
- in common with us."
- </p>
- <p> Gorbachev and his unresponsive government are increasingly
- threatened by the revolutionary forces he has set loose in the
- land. Yeltsin failed to get his proposal for an elected
- presidency on the Russian parliament's agenda last week, so that
- debate will probably have to wait for the next regular session
- in a few months. But the mass turnout in Moscow could strengthen
- his hopes for the kind of People Power that overturned Communist
- governments in Czechoslovakia and East Germany in 1989--or,
- for that matter, Czarist Russia in 1917.
- </p>
- <p> Millions of miners and workers pre sent an even more
- serious challenge. Armies might clear streets, but they cannot
- dig coal, build turbines or take over entire industries. Shaky
- as it is now, the Soviet economy could be paralyzed by the shock
- of a summer of strikes. The country, says Michael Mandelbaum of
- the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies, has
- "a potential for a general strike."
- </p>
- <p> The government of the Soviet Union is not able to operate
- a productive economy. Last week it was unable to enforce a ban
- on demonstrations in Moscow. Gorbachev has shown a penchant for
- half measures in reform and an unwillingness to return fully to
- the dark days of rule by the iron fist--and that has resolved
- nothing. Like the old A merican embassy that burned in Moscow
- last week, this rickety structure could go up at any time.
- </p>
-
- </body></article>
- </text>
-
-